Bloggers

The DOJ's New Olmstead Notice: What It Means for Your Family

Rob Gorski
The DOJ's New Olmstead Notice: What It Means for Your Family

This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more

Last week the government put something in writing. It was quiet. No press event. Just a notice in a place most people never look. But if you love someone with a disability, that notice is about your family.

What just happened

On Monday, July 20, the Trump administration's Justice Department published a notice in the Federal Register, the government's official newspaper. The notice says two things: the DOJ's own Olmstead guidance "and similar guidance documents are not enforceable," and the DOJ "will not rely upon the Olmstead Guidance" when it enforces the ADA. It's signed by Harmeet Dhillon, who leads the DOJ's Civil Rights Division — the office in charge of protecting disability rights.

What is Olmstead?

Olmstead is a Supreme Court case from 1999. Two women in Georgia, Lois Curtis and Elaine Wilson, were kept in a state hospital even though their own doctors said they didn't need to be there. They wanted to live in the community. The Court said keeping them locked away was discrimination.

That ruling gave disabled people a real right: to live at home, in their own community, with support, rather than in an institution. In 2011, the DOJ wrote a guide explaining the ruling and telling states what they had to do — things like funding services at home instead of beds in facilities. For 15 years, that guide was the playbook.

What did not change

  • Olmstead still stands. It's a Supreme Court ruling — a notice can't erase it.
  • The ADA is still the law. So is Section 504.
  • Services don't end this week because of this notice.

What did change

The rules of the game didn't change. But the referee just said he's putting away the rulebook he's used for 15 years. The DOJ's job is to step in when a state fails disabled people, and the 2011 guide told states exactly what was expected. Now the DOJ says it won't rely on that guide anymore, and it plans to rethink the guide itself. The notice itself admits that "numerous courts have treated the Olmstead Guidance as authoritative" — this wasn't a dusty memo, it was a document courts leaned on.

The third move in six weeks

This notice didn't happen alone. On June 18, the DOJ released a legal memo arguing the ADA doesn't require states to serve disabled people in the community. Since then, the administration has been backing six states in a lawsuit called Texas v. Kennedy, which asks a court to throw out the rule behind Section 504's promise of community living. Then came the July 20 notice. Three moves, six weeks, all in one direction — away from the right to live at home.

What this could mean for everyday life

Nothing changes overnight, which is exactly why this is easy to miss. Home and community services include things like a support person who helps a child or adult child get through the day, respite care, day programs and job coaches, and Medicaid waivers that pay for support at home instead of a facility bed. States decide a lot about these services, and for 15 years they knew a federal referee was watching. If that pressure eases, watch for slower waiver renewals, fewer approved hours of support, longer waitlists, more families told a facility is "the only option," and providers closing with no replacement plan. None of that is certain — it will look different in every state. But this is how rights fade in real life: not with one big announcement, but a hundred small decisions nobody is watching anymore.

What families can do right now

When Texas v. Kennedy started, nine states were suing. Three — Indiana, South Dakota, and Kansas — dropped out after families and advocates kept calling. Calling a governor or state legislator, and asking them to withdraw from cases like this, has a real track record of working.

Common questions

Did they overturn Olmstead? No. It's a Supreme Court decision and it still stands. This notice pulls back the DOJ's own enforcement guide — serious, but not the same thing.

Is the ADA still the law? Yes, along with Section 504. A notice can't repeal a law. The fight is over how those laws get enforced, and whether they get enforced at all.

Will services be lost this week? No. The risk moves slower than that — it's about what states do next, once they believe nobody is checking.

What is Texas v. Kennedy? A lawsuit where states are asking a court to strike down the rule protecting community living under Section 504. Six states remain in it; three already withdrew because of public pressure.

This post was originally published elsewhere. Read the original post →

T

Article by

The Autism Dad

Father to 3 boys with #Autism, 1 with Fragile Health. Award winning blogger, techy and advocate. #AutismDad @GuardianLocate

Disclosure: Autisable.com participates in affiliate programs, including the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate advertising programs. This means we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.

Share:

Comments

Join the community to leave a comment.